Would You Take Drugs to Be Smarter?
A few weeks ago I was watching an episode of Boston Legal in which a woman was refused admittance to Harvard because she had taken a performance enhancing prescription prior to her SAT. The reason she gave for taking this medication was to give her greater cognitive ability. The plot had the judge ruling in favor of Harvard, not because the co-ed took the drug to do better, but that she had taken it illegally without a prescription therefore violating the law causing her character to be tarnished.
WHAT? Are students really resorting to taking controlled substances just to get ahead of the game? While this show is for entertainment purposes, I had no clue that this was really going on in schools, on college campuses, and in the work place and has for some years. So I decided to do a little research on my own. Wow, what a revelation it was!
I came across an article on MSN Health and Fitness regarding the subject of taking prescription stimulant medications, such Adderall and Ritalin, in order to give one a slight edge in the work or academic environment. I must say I was flabbergasted to know that this is actually going on in an age when we have preached and preached, "JUST SAY NO” to our kids when it comes to drug use--unless of course, you want you or your child to gain admittance into a highly sought college/university or job.
I am not disputing the use of these prescriptions; in fact they play an important role for those individuals who suffer from Attention Deficit Disorder (ADD) and Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD). However, the trend is pointing to using these meds to better help those think more clearly and faster just to stay ahead of the game, even when done legally.
According to Martha Farah, PhD, Walter H. Annenberg Professor of Natural Sciences and director of the Center for Cognitive Neuroscience at the University of Pennsylvania, one study revealed that 7% of 10,000 (700 out of 10,000) college students have admitted to using these so-called ‘smart pills’ and that figure may be as high as 25% on college campuses where there is a far greater competition for students to excel.
These medications are stimulants, therefore, they increase the dopamine in the pre-frontal cortex of the brain and by doing so can raise the risk of addiction to those who abuse these med. It has been revealed that of those taking these prescriptions for non-medical purposes, 10-20% of this population will develop an addiction. What does this mean for our future when meds are being abused and not used for their intended purpose?
What concerns me most is that while these drugs have shown promise in some individuals to increase cognitive ability, it isn’t the case for everyone. And if these students aren’t getting the prescriptions from their own health care provider then where on earth are they getting them?
I do know that the DEA (Drug Enforcement Administration) monitors the physicians who prescribe these medications. They require the physician to write these prescriptions on a triplicate prescription pad that only the physician is privy to. Since these drugs are classified as amphetamines they are strictly monitored by the DEA, just like codeine, oxycodone, and morphine! I think that tells you the volatility of these drugs.
I guess I must be out of touch with what is going on within the schools, on college campuses, and work environment because until I saw this show I had no clue that this trend even existed. As the mother of a daughter in her junior year of college, I immediately called and asked if she knew of anyone taking these prescriptions or if she had been offered any or had taken them herself. Thankfully, she had not heard of this issue, but this gave me an opportunity to tell her of the risks involved in taking these drugs.
I just wonder if this is just not another pressure our society puts on our younger generation that anything less than perfect is a failure. What do you think?
Have you heard of this trend within your own community? Would you allow your child to take these medications, other than for ADD and ADHD, just so that he/she would have an edge in getting better grades or getting into a better college? Would you ever consider taking them yourself? Do you believe that this is just another symptom of a success-oriented society where first is best no matter what the cost?
WHAT? Are students really resorting to taking controlled substances just to get ahead of the game? While this show is for entertainment purposes, I had no clue that this was really going on in schools, on college campuses, and in the work place and has for some years. So I decided to do a little research on my own. Wow, what a revelation it was!
I came across an article on MSN Health and Fitness regarding the subject of taking prescription stimulant medications, such Adderall and Ritalin, in order to give one a slight edge in the work or academic environment. I must say I was flabbergasted to know that this is actually going on in an age when we have preached and preached, "JUST SAY NO” to our kids when it comes to drug use--unless of course, you want you or your child to gain admittance into a highly sought college/university or job.
I am not disputing the use of these prescriptions; in fact they play an important role for those individuals who suffer from Attention Deficit Disorder (ADD) and Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD). However, the trend is pointing to using these meds to better help those think more clearly and faster just to stay ahead of the game, even when done legally.
According to Martha Farah, PhD, Walter H. Annenberg Professor of Natural Sciences and director of the Center for Cognitive Neuroscience at the University of Pennsylvania, one study revealed that 7% of 10,000 (700 out of 10,000) college students have admitted to using these so-called ‘smart pills’ and that figure may be as high as 25% on college campuses where there is a far greater competition for students to excel.
These medications are stimulants, therefore, they increase the dopamine in the pre-frontal cortex of the brain and by doing so can raise the risk of addiction to those who abuse these med. It has been revealed that of those taking these prescriptions for non-medical purposes, 10-20% of this population will develop an addiction. What does this mean for our future when meds are being abused and not used for their intended purpose?
What concerns me most is that while these drugs have shown promise in some individuals to increase cognitive ability, it isn’t the case for everyone. And if these students aren’t getting the prescriptions from their own health care provider then where on earth are they getting them?
I do know that the DEA (Drug Enforcement Administration) monitors the physicians who prescribe these medications. They require the physician to write these prescriptions on a triplicate prescription pad that only the physician is privy to. Since these drugs are classified as amphetamines they are strictly monitored by the DEA, just like codeine, oxycodone, and morphine! I think that tells you the volatility of these drugs.
I guess I must be out of touch with what is going on within the schools, on college campuses, and work environment because until I saw this show I had no clue that this trend even existed. As the mother of a daughter in her junior year of college, I immediately called and asked if she knew of anyone taking these prescriptions or if she had been offered any or had taken them herself. Thankfully, she had not heard of this issue, but this gave me an opportunity to tell her of the risks involved in taking these drugs.
I just wonder if this is just not another pressure our society puts on our younger generation that anything less than perfect is a failure. What do you think?
Have you heard of this trend within your own community? Would you allow your child to take these medications, other than for ADD and ADHD, just so that he/she would have an edge in getting better grades or getting into a better college? Would you ever consider taking them yourself? Do you believe that this is just another symptom of a success-oriented society where first is best no matter what the cost?
![]() You will earn 3 SparkPoints |
NEXT ENTRY > Poll: Are You Feeling the Holiday Stress Yet?
































Comments
If there was a smart pill that had tons of knowledge that would give it to me instantly?
I would but I don't think I would get the same type of analytical mind I have now by investigating.
Gaining knowledge is about the connections you make on the journey to the answer, not about the answer itself. - 1/9/2011 4:50:59 PM
I DEFINITELY believe young people are being put under a great deal of pressure to perform in today's society. I live near Washington, DC and there was recently a vote to start the school day later/finish it earlier so students could get more much-needed sleep. Even the students said "No thanks." Why? Because they'd have to give up honors/AP courses, extra-curricular activities, etc. Things they HAVE to be involved in so they can get into good colleges. Good grades & SAT scores aren't enough any longer. These students get less than 5 hrs of sleep a night at a time when biologically they should be getting at least 9+ hrs/night. No wonder they need "uppers" to keep going.
Some parents aren't any help, they start pushing their children to perform at a very early age. My 10yr old nephew is on TWO youth baseball teams, he has baseball practice or a game EVERY night of the week AND on Sat AND Sun. PLUS homework. Then it's basketball season, or soccer...When do children get to be children anymore?! -Again, I can see why students turn to these "performance enhancing" drugs. It's a crying shame, literally.
PS - Provigil was what I took before Adderall, but I lost my insurance & can no longer afford it. It worked the same as Adderall -for me anyway. - 5/16/2009 7:56:56 PM
Would I try an intelligent enhancement drug..... maybe. I wish I had it when I was forced to drop out of college because my so called neurologist did not see the harmful side effects of their mind numbing medications.
Touchy subject. I think Europeans are much more open minded then we are and have far less issues about this. Watched a documentary recently and it seems we (Americans) are still one of the sickest developed nations in the world in spite of all the new diseases and peddled drug ads we succumb to everyday. Off subject but well worth the thought.
A final thought... a drug to tap into a part of ones brain to make one smart is far from being evil and wrong. I wonder if they could use this to do research for those with Alzheimers? Would it be so evil then?
- 1/17/2009 12:17:13 PM
Sam - 12/30/2008 3:46:52 PM
Definitely there are those who need medication to manage. (I myself am bipolar and couldn't function without lithium.) I'm very happy to see a number of people comment on the importance of legitimate medical prescriptions. There's nothing wrong with using what you need to manage-- we wouldn't take insulin from diabetics.
I'd also like to say, though, regarding adult ADD and ADHD-- my husband was diagnosed as a child, was prescribed Ritalin, took it for a few years and then stopped. Decades later he was "re-diagnosed" and "re-prescribed", but after comparing his feelings and performance he decided not to use the medication. That makes things harder for him, but he accepts that choice, and he uses behavioural management. He works in software, is an indispensable member of his company, makes an ungodly amount of money, and works from home under self-management very successfully.
I have another friend who's been diagnosed with adult ADHD; she's taken medication for depression but not for the attention disorder. She has a University degree and a teaching certificate now.
I just think it's good for people to know that you can pursue your goals and achieve what you want and manage your disorder (however you choose to manage it). Though now that I think about it, it does make me a little bit mad to compare "normal" students abusing medication to get an "edge" while these people I know have worked ten times as hard as anyone and probably deserve ten times more credit for it.
- 12/22/2008 11:47:39 AM
Sad, because people who need the meds aren't always taking them. It is also sad that sometimes this is prescribed a little too easily in some cases and not easily enough in others. - 12/21/2008 8:20:38 AM
Pill-Generation... Supplement-Generation... An easy chemical remedy and response for almost everything we could work out by ourself.
Am I surprised? No. - 12/20/2008 9:47:53 AM
http://www.thebetterhealthstore.com
/newsletter/09-28_SeptemberNews02.h
tml - 12/19/2008 10:24:07 PM
I have always been a high achiever in school, but have never been able to do "lightning rounds" for answers, always felt like I "froze." When I was in my early 40's, I was diagnosed with Non-hyperactive Attention Disorder. For a while, I was taking Adderall. It felt to me like I could concentrate, and the information that I knew could come out. It didn't feel like I was learning anything that I hadn't known or been able to learn before, but that I could open that lock that prevented me from reaching it quickly. If this is what these drugs are doing for the students, as long as there aren't other side effects, I don't see a problem with them.
Just a note, I no longer take this med because of other health issues, not related to taking it. - 12/19/2008 7:37:36 PM
Rosie - 12/19/2008 2:11:07 PM
I think we have to redefine the meaning of "success"; a bank teller is no less successful than an accountant; a civil servant is no less successful than an attorney. "Success" means being happy. As the show itself pointed out, no one ever said a Harvard degree automatically resulted in happiness. I wish we could put more emphasis on the validity of other goals, like self worth, diversity of interests, interpersonal relationships, global citizenship, etc. But there are no grades or degrees for these things.
I wouldn't take prescription medication illegally for any reason, but I understand the pressure to do so. My life has been far more fulfilling since I accepted being a "failure". ;-) - 12/19/2008 10:11:51 AM
A person who must take drugs to improve performance is one who will bend other rules too. One I'd not trust as my banker, lawyer, doctor, pharmacist, florist, grocer, mechanic, judge, x-ray diagnostician... etc!!! Even IF the meds were reliable in true enhancement of intellect, what happens when/if they get the degree and then go off the meds... on the job?? - 12/19/2008 2:51:59 AM
It's called ....................CLEAN EATING.
Very few are willing to 'take it'
Sad isn't it?
´¨¨)) -:¦:-
¸.•´ .•´¨¨))
((¸¸.•´ ..•´ -:¦:- Terri
-:¦:- ((¸¸.•´*
- 12/18/2008 9:53:28 PM
Sometimes I didn't know if I was coming or going with Him, But age 14, it turn around(with a lot of Prayer). He has 3 degrees now and is an Officer in the Army.
Sometimes drugs are not the best. - 12/18/2008 8:51:54 PM
My son went off the prescription in his Jr. year of high school, and while he has struggled somewhat, he is happier off of it now that he's gotten some control over his behavior, if not his mind, LOL. However, a doctor just a couple of months ago tried to convince him to go back on it so he could compete better in college and get a better job. BOTH of us were rather incensed, and told him NO.
I want my son to be happy, healthy, and to do his best in his chosen profession. I don't care if he's not the 'top of his field'. I willingly gave him his Rx when he truly needed it, and ignored those who told me I was a terrible mother for 'drugging my child' when it was a med he needed. I didn't feel bad about giving Tylenol for a fever, I wouldn't feel bad about giving a diabetic insulin, and I didn't feel bad about giving him what he needed as he needed it. But when he got old enough we weaned him off of it. Society just needs to get a collective clue about what's really important in life, I'm afraid. - 12/18/2008 6:57:07 PM
I too watched that Boston Legal episode...I am going to miss the show now that they are done. Quite a few compelling and timely issues were broached
Frankly...I am surprised that so many people responding here are surprised! No idea...yeppers!
Would i take them...depends. Our world ... our children... face stiff competition if they "want to get ahead"... "make something of themselves" and depending on variables including parental pressure the temptation to excel and meet expectations is enormous.
Where do they get them? Seriously now...you want a "magic bullet"... just ask the doctor...he has what you need to fix what ails ya! A friend of a friend might be all you need!
Telling our children to eat a well balanced diet and exercise is an exercise in futility when the pressure is this intense.
Sad commentary on the world in which we live...Indeed
- 12/18/2008 6:23:14 PM
Please Log In To Leave A Comment: Log in now ›